Treats & Toys for Spoiling Your Pet
Not sure which pick fits your person? Describe them and we'll scout tailored gift ideas.
Scout gifts for your person →Quick picks from Treats & Toys for Spoiling Your Pet
Full write-ups and more ideas are in the list below.
INABA Churu cat treats, 50-tube variety
A genuinely beloved treat in the cat world — lickable, squeezable purée that turns treat time into an event most cats go genuinely wild for, with tuna and chicken variety keeping it interesting. A large 50-tube pack means this becomes a real daily ritual rather than a one-time treat. Skip if the cat has dietary restrictions that rule out treats like this; check with their vet first if that's a concern.
Temptations classic cat treats, 30oz tub
The crunchy-and-soft alternative to the lickable purée above — one of the most recognized cat treat brands going, and a reliable pick for a cat that prefers a traditional treat over the newer purée format. A big tub means it lasts, rather than needing a refill within weeks. Skip if you've already chosen the Churu treats above; one treat variety is plenty to start.
Pur Luv chicken jerky dog treats
Real chicken breast jerky rather than a mix of fillers, which matters to owners who read ingredient labels closely. High in protein and satisfying enough to serve as a genuine chew rather than a quick snack, which most dogs appreciate more than a small biscuit. Skip if the dog has a poultry allergy or sensitivity.
Opens Amazon with a search matched to this idea — pick the listing you like.
Spoiling someone's pet is one of the safest, most reliably appreciated gift categories out there, largely because most pet owners are happy to see their animal get a little extra attention regardless of the specific brand. This list leans into that reliability, starting with the treats that get the most enthusiastic reactions before moving into dental care and a genuine toy.
The cat treats and dog treats at the top of this list are grouped by species for a reason — INABA Churu has become something close to a phenomenon in cat-owning circles specifically, while Pur Luv and Blue Buffalo appeal to dog owners who pay close attention to real ingredients over fillers. Both approaches are valid gifts; the difference comes down to what kind of pet you're shopping for.
Worth being direct about the two dental chew brands: Greenies and Dentastix solve the identical problem, dressing up real dental care as a treat a dog actually wants. Pick one rather than running both at the same time, and put the savings toward the toy at the end of this list instead.
The interactive chew toy closes things out as the one item here that isn't consumable — a genuine, lasting gift rather than something that gets eaten within a week. Pairing a treat with the toy makes for a complete, well-rounded gift that covers both the immediate reaction and something with staying power.
Related reading: Gifts for Pet Owners, and Gifts for Someone Who Just Got a New Puppy.
Gift picks
Tap Shop on Amazon on any pick — each button opens a search matched to that idea.
As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.
INABA Churu cat treats, 50-tube variety
A genuinely beloved treat in the cat world — lickable, squeezable purée that turns treat time into an event most cats go genuinely wild for, with tuna and chicken variety keeping it interesting. A large 50-tube pack means this becomes a real daily ritual rather than a one-time treat. Skip if the cat has dietary restrictions that rule out treats like this; check with their vet first if that's a concern.
Temptations classic cat treats, 30oz tub
The crunchy-and-soft alternative to the lickable purée above — one of the most recognized cat treat brands going, and a reliable pick for a cat that prefers a traditional treat over the newer purée format. A big tub means it lasts, rather than needing a refill within weeks. Skip if you've already chosen the Churu treats above; one treat variety is plenty to start.
Pur Luv chicken jerky dog treats
Real chicken breast jerky rather than a mix of fillers, which matters to owners who read ingredient labels closely. High in protein and satisfying enough to serve as a genuine chew rather than a quick snack, which most dogs appreciate more than a small biscuit. Skip if the dog has a poultry allergy or sensitivity.
Blue Buffalo pumpkin and cinnamon dog biscuits
Oven-baked biscuits made with real pumpkin and no artificial flavors or preservatives, which appeals to owners specifically looking for a treat that feels a step above a standard grocery- store biscuit. A nice, wholesome-feeling gift for a dog owner who pays close attention to what's in their pet's treats. Skip if the dog has shown sensitivity to pumpkin or grain-based treats.
Greenies dental dog treats
A genuinely useful dental chew that does double duty as a treat and as real preventive care for a dog's teeth, which is a much easier sell to a dog than a toothbrush. Vet-recommended and widely trusted. Skip if you're also considering the Dentastix below; either one covers the same dental-treat need.
Pedigree Dentastix large dog treats, variety pack
The alternative to the Greenies above, in a beef-and-fresh variety pack that offers a bit more flavor rotation. Solves the identical dental-care-as-treat need, so it's worth picking one or the other rather than stocking both at once. Skip if you've already chosen the Greenies; there's no need for two dental chew brands running at the same time.
Milk-Bone original dog biscuits, 10lb box
The classic, no-frills biscuit nearly every dog owner grew up giving their own dog — reliable, affordable in bulk, and a safe default when you're not sure what else to get. A 10-pound box means this lasts a genuinely long time. Skip if the owner has already moved toward more premium or specialty treats and wouldn't reach for a classic biscuit anymore.
Interactive squeaky crinkle dog chew toy
The one genuine toy on this list, built for dogs who live for fetch and chew time — a crinkle-and-squeak design that holds up to real play rather than falling apart in one session. A great pairing with any of the treats above for a complete "spoil the dog" gift. Skip if the dog already has a favorite toy they're devoted to and doesn't need a new one.
Want a tighter fit?
Not sure which treats & toys for spoiling your pet pick is right?
We'll scout gift ideas tailored to your person — relationship, budget, and interests pre-filled from this guide.
Scout picks tailored to this guide →Frequently asked questions
What's the best treat gift for a cat owner?
INABA Churu tubes are the most consistently beloved option in the cat world right now — the lickable format tends to get an enthusiastic reaction that traditional crunchy treats don't always match, though the Temptations tub is a great classic alternative.
Do I need to buy both dental chew brands?
No — Greenies and Dentastix solve the same problem in slightly different flavors and formats. Pick one; there's no benefit to running two dental chew brands for the same dog at once.
What's a good gift for a dog owner who reads ingredient labels closely?
The Pur Luv chicken jerky and the Blue Buffalo biscuits both lean into real, recognizable ingredients rather than fillers, which tends to matter a lot to owners who are particular about what they feed their dog.
Is a toy or a treat a better gift for a dog?
Both work well together — treats get used up and appreciated immediately, while a good toy like the interactive squeaky chew has staying power as something the dog returns to for months. Pairing one of each makes for a more complete gift.
What's a safe, universally appreciated pet treat gift?
Milk-Bone biscuits and Temptations cat treats are both classic, widely loved options that work well when you don't know the pet's specific preferences or dietary needs.
Should I check for allergies before gifting pet treats?
Yes — treats built around a specific protein, like the chicken jerky, aren't a safe choice if the pet has a known food allergy or sensitivity. When in doubt, ask the owner or stick to a treat with simple, common ingredients.